TY - JOUR
T1 - Policy makers' perspectives on the expansion of renewable energy sources in chile's electricity auctions
AU - Nasirov, Shahriyar
AU - Cruz, Eugenio
AU - Agostini, Claudio A.
AU - Silva, Carlos
N1 - Funding Information:
The regulatory framework for the power sector in Chile was enacted in 1982. (General Law of Electric Services (Decreto con Fuerza de Ley 4)). It was one of the first deregulatory processes in the world to introduce an unbundled and privately owned electricity sector (Biblioteca del Congreso Nacional de Chile, 1982) [16]. The Chilean case thus became a standard reference for many countries involved in deregulation processes in electricity markets. The power sector functions under separate segments: generation, transmission, and distribution, and all investment decisions are private. After deregulation, a few changes have been introduced, including the introduction in 2005 of a competitive, nondiscriminatory auction mechanism with the goal of providing transparent market prices, reduce uncertainty for investors, and foster competition among new entrants and existing providers [17]. In terms of the mains actors involved, the Ministry of Energy, the National Energy Commission (CNE), and the distribution companies work closely together to implement the energy auctions. The Ministry of Energy is responsible for establishing the auction rules and the country’s energy policy. Auctions are carried out by the regulator (CNE), and the contacts are signed between the winning generators and the distribution companies as off-takers. The initial design of the energy auctions was aimed at providing supply security in the regulated distribution market, giving a higher level of autonomy to distribution companies. For this reason, distribution companies were responsible for forecasting their demand and organizing auctions to manage their energy contract portfolio [18]. The key features and stakeholders of the Chilean energy auctions are presented in detail in Table A1.
Funding Information:
Multicriteria Decision Making Power Purchase Agreement Renewable Energy Sources Comisión Nacional de Energía Interconnected Central System Northern Interconnected System Multicriteria decision analysis Analytical Hierarchy Process Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluations Novel Approach for Imprecise Assessment and Decision Evaluations Stochastic Multicriteria Acceptability Analysis Technique for Order Performance by Similarity to Ideal Solution Closeness Coefficient International Renewable Energy Agency
Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 by the authors.
PY - 2019/10/30
Y1 - 2019/10/30
N2 - Chile has become one of the first few countries where renewable sources compete directly with conventional generation in price-based auctions. Moreover, the results of energy auctions during the last few years show a remarkable transition from conventional fossil fuels to renewable energies. In fact, the energy auction in 2017, to provide energy to customers from distribution companies, achieved a massive expansion in renewable technology at one of the lowest prices in the world. These positive results prompted the question if such results were permanent or temporal due to factors with limited effects. In this regard, this paper studies the key factors that drove the significant rise of renewable technologies in Chilean energy auctions, obtaining valuable lessons for regulators, not only in Chile, but also in the region and the world. For this purpose, we considered a well-proven method based on a hybrid multicriteria decision-making model to examine and prioritize the main drivers of the expansion of renewables in auctions. The results showed that some specific characteristics of the auction design, particularly the hourly supply blocks, the lead time for project construction, and contract duration, were the most significant drivers for the expansion of renewables in energy auctions. Moreover, the results showed that, provided that the auction design accommodates for such drivers, solar energy ends up as the most attractive technology in the Chilean auctions. The research also shows the main findings are robust by the application of a probabilistic sensitivity analysis.
AB - Chile has become one of the first few countries where renewable sources compete directly with conventional generation in price-based auctions. Moreover, the results of energy auctions during the last few years show a remarkable transition from conventional fossil fuels to renewable energies. In fact, the energy auction in 2017, to provide energy to customers from distribution companies, achieved a massive expansion in renewable technology at one of the lowest prices in the world. These positive results prompted the question if such results were permanent or temporal due to factors with limited effects. In this regard, this paper studies the key factors that drove the significant rise of renewable technologies in Chilean energy auctions, obtaining valuable lessons for regulators, not only in Chile, but also in the region and the world. For this purpose, we considered a well-proven method based on a hybrid multicriteria decision-making model to examine and prioritize the main drivers of the expansion of renewables in auctions. The results showed that some specific characteristics of the auction design, particularly the hourly supply blocks, the lead time for project construction, and contract duration, were the most significant drivers for the expansion of renewables in energy auctions. Moreover, the results showed that, provided that the auction design accommodates for such drivers, solar energy ends up as the most attractive technology in the Chilean auctions. The research also shows the main findings are robust by the application of a probabilistic sensitivity analysis.
KW - Auctions
KW - Chile
KW - Regulator's perspective
KW - Renewable energy
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075545160&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.3390/en12214149
DO - 10.3390/en12214149
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85075545160
SN - 1996-1073
VL - 12
JO - Energies
JF - Energies
IS - 21
M1 - 4149
ER -